Shelley L. Fish

Shelley L. Fish, 60, of Bucktooth Run, Little Valley, NY died Tuesday morning, June 16, 2026 at home following a long illness.

Born September 9, 1965 in Wellsville, NY, she was the daughter of Steven and Sharon Austin Raub. She was married in Bucktooth Run on August 24, 1996 to Robert “Bob” Fish Jr., who predeceased her in 2022.

She was a graduate of Little Valley High School, Class of 1983, and earned her Associate’s Degree from Jamestown Community College.

Shelley had co-owned and operated the Plaza Restaurant with her husband for over 30 years.

She enjoyed spending time with her family and playing with the dogs. She also enjoyed the outdoors, boating, gardening, working around the lawn, and spending time at camp.

Surviving besides her parents are: a son, Robert (Julia) Magiera II, Indianapolis, IN; a daughter, Danyle (Santo) Cafferky, Summerville, SC; four grandchildren, Brantley Cafferky, Presley Cafferky, Lily Cafferky, all of Summerville, SC, Colby Magiera, Indianapolis, IN; a brother, Travis Raub; her #1, Dennis Hill, Salamanca, NY; several nieces and nephews.

She was predeceased by three brothers, Shawn Raub, Scott Raub, and Steven Raub.

Friends may call at the O’Rourke & O’Rourke Inc Funeral Home, 25 River Street, Salamanca, NY on Thursday, June 25, 2026 from 11 a.m. – 1 p.m., at which time funeral services will be held with Rev. Michael Trenchard of the St. John’s Community Church, Cattaraugus, officiating.

Burial will be in Crawford Cemetery.

In lieu of flowers, the family suggests memorials to the Christmas Sharing Program, c/o Cattaraugus Community Action, 25 Jefferson St #1, Salamanca, NY 14779.

E-condolences can be sent to orourke.orourkefh@gmail.com or posted to facebook.com/onofh.